best 3d sonic?

[X-3]

Sonic Heroes gets my vote. Yeah. It's my favorite 3-D game, evn if 90% of the population of Earth hates it.

[Tails the Fox]

SA2 was definitely the 3d peak.... but S2 was the peak of Genesys... so the only trendbraker is i liked Sonic Advance 1 the most lol

[Curry]

tie between Sonic heroes and Shadow. Shadow had great characters, great cutscenes, great levels,great bosses. CRAPPY GAME PLAY!!!!!!
Sonic heroes was just fun.

[Apollo the Just]

SONIC ADVENTURE 2, BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Valentine]

Hard choice. I loved SA2 enough to get all 180 emblems and spend hours raising my cool dark and light chaos but the OST was nowhere near as good as the one for the original SA and it's more nostalgic cos it reminds me of the first day I got a Dreamcast.

[Bandit]

I liked SA2 the best, personally.

I've never played Heroes or Shadow, but, I was not fond of SA1.

[Yoshi1010]

sonic adventure or sonic adventure 2

[spooky scary bearatons]

Shadow, hands down, in my opinion had alot more fun in it than SA2, SA1 and SH.

I guess I like fast shadow based TPS games.