Dr Who Discussion Thread (new season starts September 2012)

[Nomyt]

Ah I see.

So last night was "The Power of Three" but I think " The Slow Invasion" would have been better, or even "Cubed" (it was originally going to be called that). These small, black cubes appear on Earth over night. Not very big, and they don't seem to do anything either. What do these Black cubes want?....I found this a fairly long episode to sit through, and near the ending the Doorbell went, and they spoke over everything, so will have to watch that bit again.....(they was worried they couldn't get through on the phone, and no one was answering mobiles, that's because we take the phone off the hook and switch Mobs to silent when DW is on!! We have done since Series 1 with CE!!)

Back from the rant. Next weeks episode looks better, but still this series has been excellent so far.

[Nomyt]

"The Angels Take Manhattan" just aired a little while ago.....still a little bit confused at the ending, but it was still a great episode. Better than last weeks. Am sad that we now have to wait till Christmas. Five episodes just doesn't seem enough. :/

[CaptHayfever]

[spoiler]*coughtheexactsamethinghappenedtoAmy&RorythathappenedtoCharlieintheseriesfinaleofHeroescough*[/spoiler]

And remember, "I'm-a Luigi, number one!"

[Rainbow Dash]

or, you know, what happened to people in blink

[CaptHayfever]

Did "Blink" feature [spoiler]the time-travelling hero's energetic red-headed companion suddenly sent back in time by an unforeseen threat just after they thought she was finally safe, the hero unable to rescue her but ultimately finding out that she got to live out the rest of her days happily with a man she loved?[/spoiler] 'Cause Heroes had that happen.

And remember, "I'm-a Luigi, number one!"

[Rainbow Dash]

i dont see why you bothered to mention the thing in the first place because it's already an established who thing vOv

[Nomyt]

Hmmmm So what's final about [spoiler] being sent back in time by the Angels....okay so the Doctor can't travel to Manhattan, because of all the time problems....so why can't Amy and Rory move out of Manhattan, as far as I can tell, nothings stopping them. We see Rory could have always gone back the to die when he gets too old. And there's always been ways of getting messages back to the Doctor (ie, could have been on the page that he ripped out of Melody/Amelia's book? or is that too easy? [/spoiler]

[Rainbow Dash]

[spoiler]its more rory and amy are letting go also angels sending people back causes fixed points in time anyway[/spoiler]

[MeowMan]

Hmmmm So what's final about [spoiler] being sent back in time by the Angels....okay so the Doctor can't travel to Manhattan, because of all the time problems....so why can't Amy and Rory move out of Manhattan, as far as I can tell, nothings stopping them. We see Rory could have always gone back the to die when he gets too old. And there's always been ways of getting messages back to the Doctor (ie, could have been on the page that he ripped out of Melody/Amelia's book? or is that too easy? [/spoiler]

[spoiler]Because the gravestone already told them that they were going to die, it became a fixed point in time. No way around it.[/spoiler]

[Nomyt]

[Spoiler] Hmmmmm the only thing about that being a fixed point in time, is that Rory Williams aged 82 dies in New York. Just liked The Doctor dies at Lake Silencio on 22nd of April 2011 at 5.02pm....he didn't stop there 40 years before hand. He traveled, and he just went there to die. As I said, Amelia and Rory could have still travelled with the Doctor for another 20 to 40 years, before either of them has to stay there in manhattan to die.[/Spoiler]